« Instant Message Handle |
Main
| Social Media, Defined »
December 06, 2005
Bill Brown on Tag Punctuation
Posted by Stowe Boyd
Bill Brown levels a really good complaint about the lack of standards around what I call tag punctuation: the delimiters that are used to separate a list of tags:
[from Tag formats: Can't we all just get along? - Signal vs. Noise (by 37signals)]
What if I want to tag something “white house” instead of with the separate tags “white” and “house” (which changes the meaning) or “whitehouse”/”white+house” (unintuitive)? Enter comma delimited tagging.
He goes on to list a variety of services -- Flickr, Amazon, 43Things -- and there is little consistency.
At Technorati, I use "+" to tie words together, like "compound+phrase", because I am creating the tags in HTML URLs, and blanks don't work well there, but T'rati changes the plus to a blank. Some services won't allow plus signs in tags, which is a pain. Some people use "wikiword" style, with all the words smooshed together.
It would be good if a standard emerged for punctuation, so I propose the following:
- All tag solutions should allow blanks and other special characters in tags except for comma. [Then I could forego the use of "+".]
- commas should be used to delimit tags in a list.
Comments (1)
+ TrackBacks (0) | Category: Technology
- RELATED ENTRIES
- Reminder -- /Message
- /Message - A New Blog
- The Individual Is The New Group -- Part 1
- 1000 Tags: Tag Advertising
- Social Ethics And Technology Design
- Nancy Hass on In Your Facebook.com
- Black and White and Dead All Over: Is Newsprint Dead?
- Anonymous Trolls, Beware: You Are Breaking Federal Laws
1. Chris Pointon on December 7, 2005 03:43 PM writes...
What a classic data-processing conundrum.
I suggest going the CSV route and adding quoted tags, so you can include commas if they're really necessary (can't think of an example right now, but I bet there is one!).
So you might have "Paris, Texas",Nastassja Kinski,Kinski,Nastassja,"Kinski, Nastassja", """Dark was the night"""
I it's probably against the quick-and-dirty tagging ethos, but most of the time you wouldn't need anything other than the commas. At least you'd have a format that wouldn't need changing again in the future.
All about CSV in the Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comma-separated_values
Permalink to Comment