Lucy on Reminder -- /Message
Janna on The Week Ahead
Elaine on Reminder -- /Message
Elaine on The Week Ahead
omaha hold em on Mary Jo Foley on Microsoft Needs To Say No To Web 2.0
morgan on John Cass on Nokia N90 Blogger Campaign
bobbie on Corante 2.0: Hubs In A Network Of Stars
tim on Get Real Minute 29 Nov 2005
penis enlargement: penis enlargement
online backgammon: online backgammon
Upskirt: Upskirt
Hot Teens: Hot Teens
from Jhony: :-)
from Jhony: :-)
poker online: poker online
from Jhony: :-)
from Jhony: :-)
from Jhony: :-)
[2004-08-23 Update: Jas Dhillon's comments of 22 August, and my clarification are presented in a new entry.]
[2004-08-21 Update: recent flapdoodle over Multiply has led to a lot of new hits on this story -- see Slicing Social Spam Both Ways. I don't believe that email invitations to join social software is "spam", in the sense that it is generally used, a point I did not make clear in this piece, although I did use it in scare quotes.]
Yesterday, I hoped to review the new Outlook plug-in from Zero Degrees. But what happened is a bit more than I expected.
First, the tool supports finding uncaptured email addresses in messages -- which sounds like a helpful feature. I ran that, and discovered a few hundred email addresses that could be helpful to save, although a lot of them were various 'support' and 'info' addresses from emails directed to me from online services and product companies. Wading through them to decide which ones to keep permanently is a chore that I was not ready to face.
But I thought it would be good to upload my contacts to Zero Degrees' server -- as a backup, before proceeding with other contact housekeeping. However, Zero Degrees -- apparently in response to customer requests to simplify the use of the tool -- has made uploading and inviting all contacts as single step process! As a result, my one mouse click led to hundreds (maybe 1000+) people getting invited to join my Zero Degrees network.
If you are one of the many that I have 'socially spammed' -- apologies. Be warned if you are signing up that the Outlook plug-in has potentially unexpected consequences for users.
It is interesting to see how many positive responses this has led to, however. At least 30 people have signed up to Zero Degrees as a result of the invitations, so far. I have received dozens of rejection emails, as well, associated with out of date email addresses -- which Zero Degrees does not manage in any way. I also have several 'please remove me from your mailing list' requests, and several folks have deflected the invite with a counter invitation to LinkedIn or Spoke.
The Zero Degrees service has many attractive features -- which I will review at a later date, once the dust has settled on this little contretemps -- and has attracted a lot of positive comments from those who have signed up. But the company will have to reinstitute the multi-step, checks-and-balance approach for the Outlook plug-in: in the meantime, don't click the button to upload all your contacts!
[Note: I see Ross Mayfield is warning folks over at Many2Many.]
[Note: I see Chris Allen got burned, too.]
Yes, I've fallen prey to the Zerodegrees virus as well. I've spent the entire morning explaining what has happened to a few dozen of my friends. What's even more troubling is that I've spammed contacts who I would NEVER send a mass email to; people at the top of the food chain who would never participate in this kind of thing. Now, I've put my social capital into play with virutally everyone I know, and very little good can come of it. If my contacts (who trust me and my judgement) make the same mistake I did, I will be to blame.
ZeroDegrees needs to send out a mass email to every person who has received an invitation and explain the situation. Not only is this a fatal flaw in their business model (which I do not believe they will ever recover from), but it illustrates a fundamental misconception among a number of the advocates of these emerging collaborative technologies; social networks don't grow virally; discovery, trust, and interaction happen over time. Attempts to artificially accelerate that process can easily lead to unintended consequences, even if at first glance good things are possible. If we don't understand and respect these laws of nature, bad things can happen. The analogy of steroid use comes to mind...
Permalink to Comment
Hay!
I got spammed by both you and Chris.
:-)
Permalink to CommentI got spammed by you too...too funny...let us know how many joined the network...that would be interesting.
Permalink to CommentStowe - I got spammed by you - but I didn't realize that until I had spammed a ton myself - I am not sure if I just didn't read the message well enough, but it surprised the heck out of me.
No problem Stowe. I am still tired from the Orkut experience anyway.
Permalink to CommentAnd I thought I was really invited by you. Unfortunately they are a bit picky about their customers and don't support anything beside IE.
Permalink to CommentApologies to my entire address book,for spamming them, bad news this product. The wording made promises it didn't keep. I would seriously question this tools maturity.
Permalink to CommentI have to add I was a victim too. Hope they will change their application. Although the outlook plug-in was an easy and convenient tool for uploading addresses to their server, I was horrified to find out that I had unknowingly spammed everybody in my address book in the process! There needs to be some privacy guidelines set, or at least some warnings on what these tools will do. The plus side was I heard back from a lot of people in my addressbook that I hadn't been in touch with for a while.
I just reviewed these blog entries on ZeroDegrees and wanted to set the record straight - also see STOWE BOYD'S CORRECTION TO HIS ORIGINAL BLOG.
ZeroDegrees never on its own initiative emails out invitations to any members contacts - EVER. Only the member who owns the contacts can invite them to join ZeroDegrees and connect with them. The only way that ZeroDegrees could have sent out the invitations is if you actually clicked on the Email Invitations button this is the last step of the invitation process. We also provide all new members who have uploaded their contacts to ZeroDegrees multiple options to "OPT-OUT or CANCEL" uploading and inviting their contacts at every step of the contact upload/invite process. Even at the last step in the contact upload/invite process you have the option to cancel by clicking on the (NOT NOW) button.
Our messaging is very clear and unambiguous about what happens at each step of the process. Members can always "OPT-OUT" of the process at any time.
Permalink to Comment
Tracked on April 15, 2004 12:24 PM
Annoyed by Zero Degrees from Life With Alacrity I experimented today with Zero Degrees, but it spammed my contacts with no warning. (more details in post.) [Read More]Tracked on April 15, 2004 01:53 PM
Social Software needs to show the seams from Joi Ito's Web Although I think the "socially awkward problem" of the social networking sites is a problem, I think the "suck up... [Read More]Tracked on April 20, 2004 10:36 PM
Joi on PETS (privacy enabling tech services) from Marc's Voice Social Software needs to show the seams . [Read More]Tracked on April 21, 2004 01:10 AM
May 20, 2004: Social Networking Talk for AMA Boston Chapter Meeting from Cesar Brea's Weblog I'm giving a talk titled "Social Networking Solutions for the Enterprise" on May 20, 2004, at a meeting of the Boston chapter of the American Marketing Association. [Read More]Tracked on May 5, 2004 02:30 PM
YASNS Watch: What up with Multiply? from Many-to-Many Reminiscent of the Zerodegrees spamming incident, I’m getting spammed by requests to join Multiply. Is this happening to anyone else? As for the service itself, so far, it looks like a standard YASNS, with an emphasis on broadcast messages, in... [Read More]Tracked on August 12, 2004 06:04 AM
Henshall's Manifesto for Social Networks from Get Real Stuart Henshall picks up the banner for a social networking manifesto, along the lines of the "Ten Commandments" gauntlet I threw down the other day over at Unbound Spiral. He wants to enlarge the scope of the discussion that has... [Read More]Tracked on August 24, 2004 09:03 AM
About Us |
Advertise |
Contact Us |
Privacy Policy |
Terms of Use
